Hagberg Consulting

Building and Upgrading the Team

Getting The Right People On The Bus

By Dr. Rich Hagberg · Published September 6, 2020 · 6 min read

Building the senior team is critical to the organization’s success and an important part of the leader’s job. But often, the criteria for selecting team members and the process for recruiting, interviewing, selecting, and onboarding are flawed or haphazard. Hiring decisions that are made with too great a sense of urgency can lead to disaster.

Key takeaways

  • Building the senior team is critical for organizational success and a primary leader responsibility.
  • Flawed or haphazard recruiting and selection processes often lead to poor hiring decisions.
  • Avoid too narrow a model for candidates, such as academic pedigree or specific intellectual style.
  • Effective team members possess experience, problem-solving ability, openness, and a positive personal style.
  • Leaders of great companies prioritize getting the right people on the bus before setting direction.

Today, the competition for top talent is intense. Chances are that you will have to balance the need to put someone in place with your desire to hire the best. Until the organization has a reputation/brand, and financial resources, it may be difficult to attract top talent. The competitive hiring market also doesn’t allow you to have “A” players in every position, although that may be desirable. However, there are certain things to look for that will give you a better chance at hiring successful team members.

Having too narrow a model of the kind of person you prefer, whether that be academic pedigree, experience at a well-known successful company, or a particular type of intellectual or interpersonal style, can be a trap. Some companies lean toward hiring people who are highly intelligent, while others have a preference for people with good interpersonal skills. One of my corporate clients over-indexed for hiring people who made a good first impression and had good interpersonal skills. They ended up hiring talent whose need to be liked was greater than their ability to execute and get results, and who also wanted to avoid conflict! Personally, I had to learn that people I resonated with on the level of ideas were not always the right fit for a job that demanded attention to details and execution.

So, what should you look for when choosing talent and/or constructing your own executive team? Through extensive research (explained in their book, When Teams Work Best) Frank LaFasto and Carl Larson identified six factors that distinguish effective from ineffective team members. They are:

1. Experience: Practical knowledge of the area or function, grasp of technical capabilities and needs, breadth and depth of experience and a record of success that is relevant to the organization’s major objectives.

2. Problem solving ability: One of the functions of a team is to solve problems, so an effective team member must have the ability to identify and clarify issues, understanding the relevant facts and their implications. He or she must be able to stay focused, make decisions, and proactively solve problems.

3. Openness: To get the most out of your team as a problem-solving group, you need people who are willing and able to say what’s on their minds and openly express their point of view, including having the courage to disagree with the leader and bring up issues that need to be resolved.As the leader, you need the courage to listen to, and honestly consider, ideas and strategies that differ from your own. This will create an environment conducive to an open exchange of ideas.

4. Personal Style: The most effective team members inspire others with their positive energy and attitude. They have an infectious enthusiasm about the work and a likeable, friendly, cooperative style which makes everyone feel motivated and comfortable. People who are negative, combative, critical, and pessimistic do not help team morale. Some people who have strong technical and analytical skills can be intellectually aggressive, highly skeptical and critical of others without having awareness of the negative impact of these tendencies on their relationships.

5. Supportiveness: A team needs people who have the motivation, and the capacity, to put the good of the team above their own individual ambitions. On an effective, high-achieving team, people are supportive of each other. They share a desire and willingness to help each other succeed, and express this through mutual encouragement, a willingness to pitch in and help other team members overcome obstacles, and by putting the team’s goals above any individual agenda. Put simply, they know how to be there for each other. They are sensitive, considerate, and easy to work with.

Some people have a hard time being supportive team players. They are self-centered, focused on their own needs, agenda, and career. Some are socially competitive and need to win and be right. Some are simply determined to get their way and will use intimidation to get it. Many people are so personally ambitious and focused on their own narcissistic agenda that they are unable to be helpful and supportive of others.

6. Action orientation: It’s important that team members have a bias for action. People who talk about things but don’t do anything much are not the ones you need on your team. You want members on your team who are willing to take initiative, and who get things done, individuals who have a desire to set and achieve goals. By their example and speech, they encourage others to take action. In the interest of getting results, they are quite willing to experiment and try a different approach. This is important on all teams, but perhaps especially in a small company where the fuse is burning, you’ve got too much to do, and the money always seems to be running out.

Good To Great: Getting The Right People On The Bus

Leaders are ultimately responsible for getting the right people on the bus. An important perspective on team building comes from Jim Collins, author of Good to Great, Built to Last and other influential books. In an example that has since become famous, he compares a company to a bus, and the leader to the bus driver.

You are a bus driver. The bus, your company, is at a standstill, and it’s your job to get it going. You have to decide where you're going, how you're going to get there, and who's going with you. Most people assume that great bus drivers (read: business leaders) immediately start the journey by announcing to the people on the bus where they're going—by setting a new direction or by articulating a fresh corporate vision. On the contrary, Collins' research showed that leaders of companies that go from good to great start not with “where” but with “who.” They start by getting the right people on the bus, the wrong people off the bus, and the right people in the right seats.

One of the most important factors in creating a highly successful team is to have the right people. “Put ‘who’ ahead of strategy, ‘who’ ahead of tactics, ‘who’ ahead of technology, ‘who’ ahead of business ideas – ‘who’ ahead of everything!”

And as discussed above in the context of the LaFasto and Larson research, the people you want to gather around you, to put on your bus, are those who are both capable and inclined to put the good of the organization ahead of their personal goals, people who are not self-centered individualists who put their own career ahead of the good of the organization.

According to Collins’ research, “Level 5 leaders,” his highest rank of best leaders, “channel their ego needs away from themselves and into the larger goal of building a great company. It’s not that Level 5 leaders have no ego or self-interest. Indeed, they are incredibly ambitious–but their ambition is first and foremost for the institution, not themselves.” In other words, “We found that for leaders to make something great, their ambition has to be for the greatness of the work and the company, rather than for themselves.”.

Questions this essay answers

What's the biggest mistake founders make when hiring for senior roles?

A common mistake is too narrow a model of what a good hire looks like. Leaders over-index on academic pedigree, on experience at one specific company, or on a particular intellectual style. Some leaders also prioritize making a good first impression or strong interpersonal skills over a candidate's ability to execute and deliver results.

How can I identify effective team members for my executive team?

Six factors distinguish effective team members. Relevant experience and strong problem-solving ability. Openness to express ideas and an inspiring personal style. Genuine supportiveness for the team, and a clear action orientation. Focus on these attributes rather than superficial preferences.

What does 'getting the right people on the bus' actually mean for a leader?

It means prioritizing 'who' is on your team even before determining 'where' the company is going or its strategy. Leaders should focus on securing individuals who are capable and willing to prioritize the organization's goals over their personal ambitions, ensuring the right people are in the right seats.

What kind of personal style should I look for in a team member?

Seek team members who inspire others with positive energy and enthusiasm, possessing a likeable, friendly, and cooperative style. Avoid individuals who are negative, combative, critical, or pessimistic, as these traits can significantly undermine team morale and effective collaboration, even if they have strong technical skills.

Is personal ambition a negative trait for senior hires?

Excessive personal ambition that overshadows the team's goals can be detrimental. The most effective team members, including Level 5 leaders, channel their ambition into building a great company rather than focusing solely on their own ego or career advancement. Their drive is primarily for the institution's success.

Next step

Working through this yourself?

Bring your real situation to the AI Coach. Twenty free messages, no card.

Related essays

These cover neighboring ground from a different angle.

About the author

Dr. Rich Hagberg

Executive coach and leadership advisor. Nearly 50 years working with founders and senior executives, and author of Founders, Keepers: Why Founders Are Built to Fail and What It Takes to Succeed. About Rich →