Hagberg Consulting

Trust and Straight Talk

Corporate Culture: Distorted View from the Top

By Dr. Rich Hagberg · Published April 15, 2004 · 12 min read

Originally published in HCG Insights, Spring 2004.

Have you ever been told about a decision made by senior management and asked yourself, “Is the CEO taking stupid pills with his orange juice?” Have you ever wondered, “How could senior management be so out of touch? They don’t have a clue about how things really work around here.” Well, you’re not alone. After conducting research on 59 companies of diverse sizes and from industries across the globe, Hagberg Consulting Group (HCG) has found that management generally makes decisions with a highly distorted view of what is really going on in the organization, particularly when it comes to understanding organizational culture.

Key takeaways

  • Senior executives consistently misjudge their internal company culture, leading to flawed decisions that harm organizational performance and the bottom line.
  • Leaders mistakenly believe they foster open environments, while employees feel their input is ignored and remain hesitant to voice honest disagreements.
  • Executives frequently assume workers grasp high-level strategy, but employees often lack clarity regarding corporate objectives and their individual performance goals.
  • Privileged status blinds senior managers to organizational hierarchies and causes them to dramatically overestimate employee loyalty and commitment.

To its credit, management is often highly attuned to developments in the external world: the market, competitive landscape and customer issues. Where management often appears to be clueless is in reading the corporation’s internal landscape: its culture, climate and employees’ feelings. Not surprisingly, misconceptions about the organization impact the quality of management decisions that all too often negatively impact the bottom line.

HCG’s recent study of organizational culture sheds light on this problem. Over a period of three years, HCG surveyed employees using its proprietary Cultural Assessment Tool (CAT), which asks 120 questions about employee’s views of their organizations’ corporate culture. The survey was anonymous, but respondents were asked to indicate their level within their organization—e.g., senior management, middle management, etc. The study then compared the responses of senior management to those of all other employees. This comparison of item-level responses revealed dramatic differences.

HCG’s study identified distortions in the following areas:

Decision Making

Many of the most significant differences in viewpoints between senior management and all other employees is how decisions in the organization are made. These differences suggest major distortions that have the potential to severely degrade the quality of management’s decisions.

Decision Participation

Executives believe that they actively solicit employee input in decision making and highly value employee opinions. According to the data, they see themselves as highly participative in their management style; believe they actively seek feedback and consider themselves open to alternative views. Employees remain skeptical of management’s openness to feedback and feel their views do not receive fair consideration in decision making.

Data suggests that executives may unconsciously attempt to sell their own views to employees rather than listening to employee ideas and concerns. Also, executives may fail to recognize the intimidating effect of their position of power, and employees may not feel comfortable providing candid feedback, particularly if it involves disagreeing with management’s decisions.

Employee Interest vs. Shareholder Values

According to the data, executives feel that they care about employees, consider their welfare in decision making and try to balance the interests of employees with those of shareholders. Employees do not quite believe this and wonder if management is exclusively worshiping at the altar of shareholder value, with employee interest being only an afterthought. Employees have also become cynical after decades of layoffs, mergers, stories about management greed and ethical lapses. Clearly, pressure on management to deliver short-term results is intense. But, the need to increase shareholder value has become a common justification for a variety of management actions that put employee interests at the bottom of the priority list.

Risk Taking, Openness and Trust

Executives often assume that they have created an environment where risk taking is encouraged, nonconformity is accepted, employees feel free to disagree and conflict is openly addressed. In addition, management sees itself as being trusted by employees.

Contrary to executives’ beliefs, employees do not feel that risk taking is supported and believe that conformity is expected. They see management as allowing conflicts and disagreements to fester, leaving employees reluctant to disagree.

Other HCG research suggests that despite executives’ strong, assertive personalities, many are actually conflict phobic. As a result, they behave like ostriches and hope organizational conflicts go away. Employees are uncertain that management will always do what it says it will do and are skeptical about whether management can be trusted.

Solutions

Senior management must actively and continuously solicit input, listen to feedback and supplement what they think they are hearing with anonymous, objective feedback tools that allow them to keep a finger on the pulse of employee attitudes and opinions. Understanding employee needs, feelings and attitudes allows management to factor those understandings into their decisions.

Trust and teamwork do not happen spontaneously just because people are working in groups; they must be cultivated. Senior management needs to create an atmosphere where it is safe for employees to candidly express their views, exchange ideas and disagree with management. Working through disagreements will also build on trust and teamwork.

Communication

Senior executives believe they have clearly communicated both direction and standards of behavior. According to employees, this is not the case.

Bottom-Line Focus

Executives believe that they focus on objectives that extend beyond financial measures of success.

Although they acknowledge that they are quite attuned to financial metrics, they see this as only one of many factors influencing their decisions.

Perhaps, this difference in perspective comes from the fact that management is intimately aware of the organization’s strategy and can readily see the broader meaning and strategic rationale for various business activities and decisions.

Employees do not always see this connection and may miss the broader context.

The comparison data also suggest that executives have a much more sophisticated understanding of how to interpret financial information and how to make broader significance out of financial numbers. Employees generally have a less sophisticated understanding of the financial information and appear far less aware of either the organization’s financial goals or its recent revenues and profits.

Executives believe that they have communicated the broader significance of the organization’s mission and assume that employees see the link between financial data and strategic decisions. Management must go out of its way to communicate non-financial goals, articulate the broader meaning of the organization’s activities and help employees understand the financial results. The mission and strategy may be clear to senior management, but it is frequently unclear to those at lower levels in the organization.

Clear Performance Goals

Executives believe that individual employee performance goals have been clearly linked to the company’s larger business objectives. Senior management assumes that employees see how their day-to-day activities and priorities are connected with the organization’s strategy and business model. Again, without communication of the broader business context for decisions, employees will not see this link. In fact, they may not even be clear about what their individual performance goals are.

Standards

Quality: Paradoxically, although management has a strong belief that excellence and quality are highly valued, it appears to acknowledge that the organization often tends to have a short-term, crisis mentality. Employees feel the pressure to produce quick results but question whether quality is really valued by senior management. They see a more expedient, “Just ship it!” mentality. The pressure for short-term results can lead to expedient decisions and the compromise of standards.

Executives must realize that they live in a goldfish bowl where employees are watching their every move. The slightest compromise of standards is quickly observed and widely communicated. Years of effort to improve quality can be washed away by a few convenient compromises.

Meritocracy: Executives tend to see the organization as a meritocracy where those who get ahead have earned it. They believe that getting results, demonstrating competence and achieving excellence are recognized and rewarded by the organization. This attitude is somewhat self-serving since they are the ones who have made it to the top.

Employees often wonder if promotions are based on political connections or favoritism. They are not as certain that a true meritocracy exists. This suggests the need to establish an objective performance appraisal system, transparent career advancement criteria and the elimination of all factors other than performance in promotion and reward.

Work/Life Balance: Management believes that employees can have work/life balance and still succeed. Perhaps this is because they have more control over their own work schedules or because their expectations are more modest when it comes to actually “having a life.” By comparison, employees feel intense pressure to perform and believe that in order to get ahead they must put work ahead of everything else in their lives. There is a good deal of discussion of work/life balance these days, and this is translating into pressure on management to accommodate for flextime, telecommuting, job sharing, part-time employment and family leave. The survey data suggest that senior management, given their different perspective, may not see these concerns as very important.

Ethical Practices: In an era of Enron, WorldCom and Tyco, questions about corporate ethics are quite sensitive. The survey results show that management believes unethical business practices are extremely rare.

Employees are much less sure of the ethical purity of their organization, seeing ethical compromises as more common. Maybe employees’ standards are different. Maybe management is unaware of compromises that are taking place deep in the organization. Or, maybe management does not evaluate its own behavior as critically as it should.

Solutions

  • Senior management must massively over-communicate the organization’s mission and strategy. Management cannot assume that employees “get it.” If employees understand the strategic context, it is much easier to explain the rationale for management decisions. Formal processes need to be established for keeping employees informed about priorities, changes in direction and important events. Employees must also understand the broader strategic meaning of their day-to-day activities and individual goals.
  • The pressure for short-term results is part of today’s business reality. Compromising ethics and quality will be visible to followers and will have consequences. What may seem like a convenient compromise in the short run can damage credibility in the long run. Management must avoid the expedient “quick fix” that compromises values. They must decide what they stand for, and remain true to it.
  • Management must establish systems that increase the likelihood that those who get results are recognized and promoted. Making an effort to reduce the importance of cronyism and favoritism and instilling a fair, objective and transparent promotion criteria will increase the perception among employees that meritocracy exists.
  • Management is often fooled into believing that the list of values they created at the off-site in the mountains are really the culture values that are endorsed and practiced by the organization. Management must understand the real values that are operating in their organization’s culture.

Isolation and Insulation

Senior executives are unaware of their unique and privileged status.

Hierarchy

Executives do not see significant status differences between employees at various levels. Perhaps they fail to recognize the privileged world they live in and the status and perks afforded to them. Conversely, employees see the organization as hierarchical. They see a more clearly defined class-structure where title, office size and special privileges differentiate levels of power and status. They also see who associates with whom and who is given access to certain information.

Employee Loyalty

No matter what the current economic climate may be, organizations must be sensitive to the importance of retaining their top performers. It is disturbing to find that executives may be deluding themselves about the level of loyalty that exists in their organization. Members of senior management feel a strong sense of loyalty and commitment to the organization--this may actually be one factor in their career success. They tend to assume that others share this same feeling, but their employees are much less connected and committed. Employee loyalty is significantly lower than that of senior management. Not knowing this, senior management becomes far less attuned to the causes of unwanted turnover.

Another recent research study conducted by HCG shows that employee loyalty is positively impacted by teamwork, trust, confronting conflict, candor, meritocracy and decision participation. Loyalty also improves when employees feel they are contributing to something meaningful beyond financial objectives. In all of these areas, executives exhibit a distorted and overly idealized view of the organization’s culture. They appear to be out of touch with those factors that might be undermining employee loyalty.

Compensation

Given the generally high level of executive compensation, it is not surprising that management is happy with its compensation package. Executives believe that their job performance directly affects the compensation they receive. They believe that they get paid more because their value to the organization and their contribution merit a higher level of compensation. Employees are far less satisfied with their own compensation and are not sure that their efforts will actually influence their compensation.

Solutions

  • Management must realize that it is easy to become isolated and insulated. Executives live in a privileged world with a great deal of influence, status and access to information. They often assume that they understand how employees are feeling. This may not be the case. Top management needs to take the time to practice “management by walking around” and seek every opportunity to make both formal and informal contact with employees.
  • Organizations with a high level of employee turnover should consider conducting exit interviews and anonymous employee surveys to pinpoint causes of dissatisfaction.
  • Executives must never flaunt their power, status, special perks or financial privileges. Any behavior that creates the impression that employees are “second class citizens” should be avoided.

Conclusion

After decades of cost cutting, downsizing, mergers and scandals, employees have become cynical and distrusting toward management. Executives must keep in mind that employees are scrutinizing their every move. Unconscious and conscious behaviors are constantly being interpreted and may easily be misinterpreted. Senior management must keep in mind the following:

  • Executives live in a bubble and have special privileges and power because of their role and status. Most fail to recognize the consequences of their position power.
  • Because of this insulation, their perception of themselves and the corporate environment can become distorted.
  • This distorted view can lead to a lack of objectivity that undermines the quality of their decisions.
  • Executives are often out of touch with how their behavior impacts employees and how it is interpreted.
  • They fail to see that their random acts are being interpreted and do not realize the extent to which they unconsciously shape the organization’s culture.

Tips for Executives

There are concrete actions that executives can take to minimize the potential for developing a distorted view:

  • Go out of your way to create an atmosphere where employees feel free to tell management what is on their minds. Don’t assume you are hearing everyone’s real opinions. You must make it safe for people to surface problems and concerns and to critique management’s decisions. If you want to test management’s ability to create an atmosphere where employees feel safe to share ideas, consider measuring the number of suggestions per employee in each department.
  • Find ways to increase employee involvement in decisions. If you want their support in solving the organization’s problems, give employees an opportunity to participate in their solution.
  • Utilize surveys and other sources of anonymous feedback on an annual basis. This will help you spot any changes in employee attitudes and morale. You may feel that you have established an “open door,” but remember, some employees will never tell you the bad news directly.
  • When your initiatives meet resistance or your motives are misinterpreted, avoid the temptation to simply sell employees on your point of view. Listen first to employees’ concerns. Only when you have demonstrated that you understand their resistance should you attempt to persuade them.
  • In addition to financial performance, consider emphasizing such benchmarks as: customer knowledge, satisfaction and loyalty; the efficiency of internal business processes that ensure quality and speed to market and the ability of the organization to change and improve by continuous learning and growth.
  • You may think about your business strategy night and day. You may assume you have communicated its key elements to employees on numerous occasions. Just do not assume they have really understood it. You must dramatically over-communicate your plans and priorities. Always keep in mind that the words and ideas that are the guts of your strategy mean something very specific to you; others may not have the same understanding or any understanding.

In summary, executives must always remember that power comes with the potential for isolation and insulation. A leader must be grounded in an objective understanding about the reality of what is happening inside as well as outside the organization. Any leader who is not getting continuous, accurate information about the organization’s culture and the values, attitudes and morale of its employees, has the potential to suffer distortions in perspective, which can negatively impact the quality of their decisions. A distorted view from the top can ultimately prove fatal.

Questions this essay answers

Why do senior executives have a distorted view of company culture?

Executives often understand external market conditions well but become insulated by their status, power, and compensation perks. This bubble blinds leadership to the company's internal hierarchy, employee morale, and perceived lack of meritocracy. Without objective and anonymous feedback channels, leaders mistakenly assume employees share their personal loyalty, optimism, and understanding of corporate strategy.

Why do employees avoid giving candid feedback to senior leadership?

Employees are intimidated by executive power and fear the consequences of disagreeing with management decisions. While leaders often believe they actively welcome input, they frequently sell their own ideas rather than listen, or avoid addressing conflict directly. To fix this dynamic, leadership must proactively create safe environments for debate, work through disagreements openly, and implement anonymous feedback tools.

Why do employees struggle to connect their daily work to company strategy?

Leaders spend extensive time immersed in strategy and mistakenly assume their communication has registered with staff. Employees generally have less financial sophistication, miss the broader strategic context, and fail to see how individual performance goals tie to high-level objectives. Closing this gap requires executives to massively over-communicate mission priorities and explain the broader meaning of day-to-day operations beyond pure financial results.

What actually drives employee loyalty and retention?

Employee loyalty is driven by teamwork, trust, addressing conflict, candor, meritocracy, and direct participation in decisions. Retention also strengthens when staff feel they contribute to a meaningful purpose beyond bottom-line financial targets. Executives who assume their own high commitment is mirrored across the workforce overlook these factors, leaving them blind to the true causes of turnover.

Next step

Working through this yourself?

Bring your real situation to the AI Coach. Twenty free messages, no card.

Related essays

These cover neighboring ground from a different angle.

  • Telling the CEO the Baby Is Ugly

    Understanding and assessing your organization's culture can mean the difference between success and failure in today's fast changing business environment. Senior…

  • Getting The Right People On The Bus

    Building the senior team is critical to the organization’s success and an important part of the leader’s job. But often, the criteria for selecting team members and…

  • Psychological Safety and Creating Open Dialogue

    Good communication is vital for effective functioning of any team. However, if you have ever been on a team where the team leader openly criticizes team members…

  • 10 Founder Traits That Undermine Growth

    Startups might be thrilling, but the cold truth is that most of them fail—and it’s often the founders themselves who unknowingly set the stage for collapse. After…

About the author

Dr. Rich Hagberg

Executive coach and leadership advisor. Nearly 50 years working with founders and senior executives, and author of Founders, Keepers: Why Founders Are Built to Fail and What It Takes to Succeed. About Rich →